1910-11 C56 #35 JACK MARSHALL RC $4,186 (eBay)
Marshall’s career stands as one of the most unusual to lead to enshrinement in the Hall of Fame. The diminutive center played just 104 games, but was a part of six Stanley Cup winners between 1901 and 1914, scoring 12 goals in 15 finals contests. This auction featured a spectacular EX-MT+ copy of his key single, highlighted by bold colors and clean borders. Just two copies have graded higher, making this a perfect example for a C56 set builder or a Hall of Fame collector.