Pocketmags Digital Magazines
AU
Pocketmags Digital Magazines
   You are currently viewing the Australia version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
31 MIN READ TIME

Houdini’s Remarkable Female Detective

TERENCE HINES

Rose Mackenberg was a female private detective in the 1920s, an unusual occupation for a woman even today. She worked very closely with Harry Houdini in exposing mediums and spiritualists and continued that line of investigations and exposures after Houdini died. She was a remarkable woman, and the skeptical community knows little about her. Until the publication of this book, the only description of her was in a short piece by Loren Pankratz in the July/August 1995 Skeptical Inquirer (pp. 28–29).

Houdini’s “Girl Detective”: The Real-Life Ghost-Busting Adventures of Rose Mackenburg. Compiled and introduced by Tony Wolf. 2016. ISBN: 9-781537-143965. 93 pp. Paperback, $8; Kindle edition, $6

Wolf ’s book is described as “an illustrated anthology of Rose Mackenberg’s original 1929 newspaper article series detailing her sometimes hair-raising adventures exposing the chicanery of the ghost racket” (from the back cover). There is a thirteen-page introduction before the eight articles that Mackenberg wrote are reprinted. Wolf is too vague about the sources of these articles, saying only that they “were published as a series of weekly installments in several North American newspapers during 1929” (p. 21). The introduction describes Houdini and his interest in investigating spiritualists. However, it is totally without references to the larger literature on Houdini, which greatly limits its value. At one point, Wolf fails to follow up on a potentially important aspect of the articles. On page 17, he states that Mackenberg had “written a manuscript detailing her adventures in battling the ‘spook racket’” that she never published but that “appeared as part of an eBay estate auction during November of 2012.” And that’s all— the reader is left hanging. Ten minutes of Internet searching revealed that the lot on eBay was listed at an outrageous price—$25,000—and didn’t sell. The price did not include the right to publish the manuscript. Further, the manuscript was simply a combination of the articles Wolf has reprinted. Wolf should have included this information in his introduction.

Read the complete article and many more in this issue of Skeptical Inquirer
Purchase options below
If you own the issue, Login to read the full article now.
Single Digital Issue September October 2017
 
$4.49
This issue and other back issues are not included in a new Skeptical Inquirer subscription. Subscriptions include the latest regular issue and new issues released during your subscription.
Annual Digital Subscription $25.99 billed annually
Save
4%
$25.99

This article is from...


View Issues
Skeptical Inquirer
September October 2017
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


Editor’s Letter
The concerns of scientific skeptics cover an astonishingly wide range
NEWS AND COMMENT
When a pollster that’s been surveying public opinion about evolution
Turkey already ranked even worse than the United States in
The first few months of 2017 have not been good
The Journal of Scientific Exploration (JSE) is one of the
INVESTIGATIVE FILES
Joe Nickell, PhD, is now well into his fifth decade
A MAGICIAN IN THE LAB
James Randi began his career as a stage magician and
NOTES ON A STRANGE WORLD
The Terrifying Story of the Most Infamous Ritual Murders in Italian History, Part 2
THE SCIENCE OF SCIENCE COMMUNICATION
Facilitating Conversations about Science and Religion
BEHAVIOR & BELIEF
Stuart Vyse is a psychologist and author of Believing in
SKEPTICAL INQUIREE
Benjamin Radford is a research fellow at the Committee for
SPECIAL REPORTS
I trust that I need not persuade readers of Skeptical
In 2012, journalist John Bohannon of the respected journal Science
FEATURES
Looking through Galileo’s Lens or through the Imaginary Looking Glass
Souped-up galvanometers are being used to assess people’s health and determine what they supposedly need. Tests expose them as preposterous, and government agencies should stop their use
Why It’s Time to Get Rid of Fallacy Theory
During its history, the hairy man-beast has evolved through at least seven mythical embodiments
NEW AND NOTABLE
Listing does not preclude future review
REVIEWS
In this little red book, Don S. Lemons has assembled
President Trump—who has called climate change a “hoax” and has
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
“Surviving the Misinformation Age” (May/June 2017) offered my incredulous skeptical