You are currently viewing the Canada version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
9 MIN READ TIME
THE CONVERSATION

Should period dramas reflect modern sensibilities?

From The Forsyte Saga in the 1960s to the latest season of Bridgerton, period drama has long been a favourite genre with TV audiences. But should such shows reflect our changing tastes as viewers, or offer an accurate view of the people and periods they depict? We asked a panel of experts COMPILED BY MATT ELTON

THE BIG QUESTION

ILLUSTRATION BY HUGH COWLING
Claire Foy and Damian Lewis in the 2015 BBC adaptation of Hilary Mantel’s Wolf Hall. The casting of its sequel has sparked a backlash in some quarters
Unlock this article and much more with
You can enjoy:
Enjoy this edition in full
Instant access to 600+ titles
Thousands of back issues
No contract or commitment
Try for $1.39
SUBSCRIBE NOW
30 day trial, then just $13.99 / month. Cancel anytime. New subscribers only.


Learn more
Pocketmags Plus
Pocketmags Plus

This article is from...


View Issues
BBC History Magazine
July 2024
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


BBC History
THIS ISSUE’S CONTRIBUTORS
Kelly Clancy “We can learn a lot about
THREE THINGS I’VE LEARNED THIS MONTH
1. Back down to Earth I was interested
EDITORIAL
WELCOME JULY 2024
The transatlantic slave trade is one of the
EVERY MONTH
ANNIVERSARIES
21 JULY AD 365 Alexandria is hit by a
Nicolas Kinloch (1954–2024)
Nicolas Kinloch was a historian, teacher, traveller and
The moral of this Shakespearean tale? Always trust your primary sources!
THE SHAKESPEARE AUTHORSHIP QUESTION
We mustn’t overlook the toll of surfacing traumatic histories
HIDDEN HISTORIES
Pet protectors
LETTER OF THE MONTH
Q&A
A selection of historical conundrums answered by experts
DID YOU KNOW…?
Fuel fraud In early 1940, a conman persuaded
…it’s raining cats and dogs?
As is well-known, it never rains cats and
BOOKS
THE AMERICAS “Sacrifice was just one, much misunderstood,
“It had been a tiny triumph, but it had been a British triumph”
MAX HASTINGS talks to Rob Attar about a daring airborne raid that provided a much-needed boost to Britain’s morale in the darkest days of the Second World War
Anne Boleyn, ‘princess’ of France
JOANNE PAUL is impressed by an account of how the Tudor queen’s continental connections shaped her meteoric rise and dramatic fall
Analysing Anne
Deputy editor Matt Elton picks three episodes of the HistoryExtra podcast that profile Boleyn
An Aztec history of the Aztecs
CAROLINE DODDS PENNOCK is won over by a guide to Aztec mythology dominated by dramatic Indigenous descriptions of their world
What can 1984 teach 2024?
ROBIN BUNCE praises a book that explores George Orwell’s writings on every thing from race to censorship – and asks, what can we learn from him today?
Dancing with the Devil
ROGER MOORHOUSE is impressed by a book that traces the fortunes of the diplomats charged with managing the west’s wartime alliance with Josef Stalin
Empire of the son
Conn Iggulden discusses Nero, the first novel in his new series that dramatises the life of the infamous Roman emperor
ENCOUNTERS
COOKBOOK Victorian cucumber ice cream TRAVEL Tokyo,
“We’ve come to see George Orwell as this prophet of dystopia, but that’s only one side”
HELEN LEWIS tells us about her new radio series, co-hosted with Ian Hislop, on the 20th-century novelists Franz Kafka and George Orwell
Victorian cucumber ice cream
RECIPE
Tokyo in five places
From fishing village to imperial capital, Japan’s biggest city has been repeatedly reimagined. CHRISTOPHER HARDING picks his must-visit sights
PRIZE CROSSWORD
Across 6 Ancient Greek mathematician and astronomer who
NEXT MONTH
Crusader criminals Steve Tibble describes how the medieval
MY HISTORY HERO
Speaker of the House of Commons Sir Lindsay Hoyle chooses
FEATURES
“IT’S TIME TO WRITE WOMEN BACK INTO THESE WORLD-CHANGING ANCIENT EVENTS”
Daisy Dunn tells the story of the Greco-Persian Wars through the deeds of the extraordinary female figures who shaped them
TITANIC STRUGGLE A timeline of the Greco-Persian Wars
• c545 BC The city-states of the Greek
War and pieces
Far from idle pursuits, games have transformed the way societies have made sense of life and death, order and conflict for centuries. Kelly Clancy picks five examples that reveal how play time has often been a serious business
The Oradour-sur-Glane massacre
Little did they know that they were about to become the victims of one of the most infamous massacres of the Second World War.
Gulbadan Begum The Mughal Jane Austen
Gulbadan Begum was meant to live a quiet life in the confines of a Mughal harem. Instead she made her mark on history twice: first, embarking on a pioneering pilgrimage to Islam’s holy cities; second, writing a remarkable history of her dynasty.
Britain’s war on the slave ships
In the early 19th century, a Royal Navy squadron was sent to west Africa to hunt down ships carrying enslaved people to the Americas. The operation was hailed as an act of “pure unselfish philanthropy”. Yet, writes Mary Wills, the reality was far more tangled
FROM HELL TO FREEDOM?
The capture of a slave ship was the first step of a journey that rarely took enslaved people back to their homelands
FIVE THINGS YOU (PROBABLY) DIDN’T KNOW ABOUT…
Rob Collins, who is teaching our new HistoryExtra Academy course, shares five surprising facts about life in Britain during the Roman occupation
Succession 1603
The passing of the English crown from Elizabeth I to James VI & I was welcomed by a nation hungry for change. But, writes Susan Doran, it wasn’t long before tensions began to rise between the incoming king and his new subjects
KING JAMES’S UPS AND DOWNS
Whose fortunes surged – and whose took a nosedive – in the new Stuart regime?
ADVERTISEMENT
Signature VOYAGES
Advertisement
Advertisement
ancestry
Warnerhotels
warnerhotels.co.uk/history
London Review OF BOOKS
lrb.me/join
BBC HISTORY MAGAZINE
OURMEDIA SHOP
OURMEDIASHOP.COM/SFHA24
History Extra PODCAST
historyextra.com
PODCAST
Petersommer
www.petersommer.com
Chat
X
Pocketmags Support