Der Rosenkavalier Strauss
Too much reality – or what passes for reality in the heads of opera directors – can be a baleful thing. There is such layered suggestion and allusion in Richard Strauss’s best-loved work that shining too strong a light can shatter the magic of the shadows
UK
ROYAL OPERA HOUSE LONDON
Music ****
Staging ***
Review by Robert Thicknesse Photography by Catherine Ashmore
Robert Carsen’s light, in any case, is a tendentious one: he seems to suggest Rosenkavalier not only led directly to the First World War but maybe actually caused it. Updatings to 1911 (year of composition) are hardly rare. Jonathan Miller did it much more delicately for English National Opera, a production that was ditched, weirdly I think, for David McVicar’s painting-by-numbers job; but Carsen, in this re-pimping of a disliked 2004 Salzburg staging, angrily parses the piece as a rant against militarism and the selling of daughters (both very bad things – thanks for telling us, Mr Carsen).