GB
  
You are currently viewing the United Kingdom version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
78 MIN READ TIME

Who are we?

ROGER SCRUTON

The result of the referendum on the European Union was surprising, not only because the opinion polls and bookies did not predict it, but because the factors which gave rise to it have been held off the agenda for so long that hardly anyone was prepared to discuss them. Subsequent bitterness and disillusion have begun to bring those factors to the surface and it seems to me imperative that we discuss them now, so that we can go forward in a spirit of national unity.

I have already used two question-begging words, and indeed the very words that lie at the heart of the conflict between those who voted “remain” and those who said “leave”: the words “we” and “national.” It is we who made the decision, but who are we, and what justifies the use of the first-person plural? If we think of ourselves as a nation, then which nation do we have in mind, and how do we square the outcome of the vote with the fact that England and Wales chose “leave,” while Scotland and Northern Ireland opted for “remain”? Indeed, on some readings of the event, it is no longer possible, a er the vote, to think of the United Kingdom in national terms at all. Perhaps it is true that those who voted “leave” were expressing their attachment to an older form of collective identity—the “we” of the nation, shaped and hardened by European wars—while those who voted “remain” were identifying with a global, outward-looking project that has the abolition of nations as its dominant aim. But it has not been true for a long time that the UK is a single national entity: it is at best a group of nations under a single sovereign, now being pulled apart by Europe’s gravitational field.

Although the Scottish people voted to remain in Europe, the Scottish First Minister Nicola Sturgeon sees this as a vote for national independence rather than a vote to be governed from Brussels. And while it is true that the question of identity—of who “we” are—was at issue in all parts of the Kingdom, the “leave” vote was more about self-government and sovereignty than any articulate idea of nationhood. The English and Welsh have little desire to separate from the kingdom that includes them, or to make national identity into the source of government. Rather they objected to being bossed about by people whom they had not elected.

Read the complete article and many more in this issue of Prospect Magazine
Purchase options below
If you own the issue, Login to read the full article now.
Single Digital Issue August 2016
 
£5.99 / issue
This issue and other back issues are not included in a new subscription. Subscriptions include the latest regular issue and new issues released during your subscription. Prospect Magazine
PRINT SUBSCRIPTION? Available at magazine.co.uk, the best magazine subscription offers online.
 

This article is from...


View Issues
Prospect Magazine
August 2016
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


Editor’s Letter
A result, but no conclusion
The European Union referendum delivered a startling result—but not a
This month
If I ruled the world
If I ruled the world my first edict would be
Prospect recommends
In 2009, Nicky and Robert Wilson launched Jupiter Artland just
Prospect events
The Prospect Book Club meets every third Monday evening of
Letters
Rachel Sylvester is right to ask if the Tories face
In fact
Per capita, the United States employs many more prison guards
Opinions
The next generation will suffer most
My dad, post-war Atlanticist and Empire nostalgic as he was,
Does China care about Brexit?
Here in China, state television followed the European Union referendum
Never say never
The Leave campaign won the referendum battle—the question is now
The Republicans’ unloved leader
Can Donald Trump be stopped—not in November, but sooner, by
The end of Hinkley Point C?
Hinkley Point C is vulnerable to the effects of Brexit
Information overload
In a world where a ceaseless barrage of information, opinion,
Analysis
Chilcot’s tough lesson
There was a time in 10 Downing Street when it
The Prospect Duel
Should we stop subsidising opera?
Each year the UK’s major opera companies receive around £65m
Features
Welcome to New Britain
The EU referendum has caused the biggest upheaval in British
Europe’s biggest threat
Britain’s referendum laid bare the extent to which society—across Europe—is
It’s not over until it’s over
If there is one fixed point in the hurricane of
Arguing with the EU
Breaking up is hard to do. The British people voted
A vote against the mass immigration society
The Brexit vote was evidently not just about immigration. But
A national trauma
The European Union referendum was the most politically traumatic event
Alone at the top
On the evening of 28th October 1971, the day on
The trapped country
When President Dilma Rousseff lit the Olympic torch in May
The science of the inconceivable
Late last year, an experiment carried out by scientists at
13 ways of looking at Steven Spielberg
To explore your medium, to revisit childhood, to have paying
Arts & books
Flights of the dream bird
by Walter Benjamin, translated by Sam Dolbear, Esther Leslie and
Race to the bottom
British Airways (BA) used to forbid its cabin staff from
The long road to victory
In August 1941, Winston Churchill and Franklin D Roosevelt met
Visions of the faraway
In January 1923, a 35-year-old painter named Georgia O’Keeffe mounted
Books in brief
The Myth of Meritocracy: Why Working-Class Kids Still Get Working-Class
Life
Leith on life
Call it a reaction-formation. Having spent much of the last
Life of the mind
I was having coffee with a friend the other day
Matters of taste
This spring I was in Beirut for several weeks and
Wine
How can you sample some of the world’s greatest wines
DIY investor
Paul Lewis, the presenter of BBC Radio 4’s MoneyBox, published
Endgames
The way we were
On 18th January, 1963. Tony Benn, Labour MP, writes in