GB
  
You are currently viewing the United Kingdom version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
120 MIN READ TIME

Respectful Skepticism

CRAIG A. FOSTER

The 2018 Committee for Skeptical Inquiry (CSI) CSICon conference is in the books. After checking in at Las Vegas’s McCarran International Airport and consuming a mediocre breakfast burrito, I found myself next to Burger King with enough solitude and caffeine-based stimulation to process everything I learned. I have been to three consecutive CSICons; this one placed a stronger emphasis on treating others with respect.

I was part of it. In my talk, I discouraged stereotyping pseudoscience supporters as being unintelligent or mentally unwell. The speakers who preceded me discussed leading with caring and having sympathy toward those who insert Goop into their … lives. Massimo Pigliucci discussed the limits of science (Boudry and Pigliucci 2017). Paul Offit shared a longstanding wish that he could relive a previous event and express more caring. The amazing James Randi himself continued the theme. SI Editor Kendrick Frazier recalled a person who asked Randi about helping loved ones who believe in flim-flam. Randi’s advice was to be kind to them, because they have trouble understanding how they have been misled.

Unfortunately, people simply do not recognize the im-portance of behaving respectfully and then change their modus operandi for interacting with others. The challenges associated with creating more respectful behavior are evident at my institution, the United States Air Force Academy. Some might think it odd that an institution would care about respect when its graduates might be asked to kill people. On the contrary, the U.S. Air Force Academy cares a great deal about respect, recognizing that it can reduce unnecessary harm, facilitate a positive workplace climate, and contribute to more effective leadership. I am pleased to say that my department, the Department of Behavioral Sciences and Leadership, has played an influential role in this process, allowing me to learn from discussions surrounding this issue. Treating people with respect is also a thread that perceptibly and imperceptibly weaves through the behavioral science courses we teach.

Read the complete article and many more in this issue of Skeptical Inquirer
Purchase options below
If you own the issue, Login to read the full article now.
Single Digital Issue March/April 2019
 
£2.99 / issue
This issue and other back issues are not included in a new subscription. Subscriptions include the latest regular issue and new issues released during your subscription. Skeptical Inquirer
Annual Digital Subscription £16.99 billed annually
Save
5%
£2.83 / issue

This article is from...


View Issues
Skeptical Inquirer
March/April 2019
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


EDITOR’S LETTER
Vitamin Megatherapy and Respectful Skepticism
My father was a small-town pharmacist, and he always told
FEATURES
ANTIOXIDANT MEGAVITAMINS FOR BRAIN HEALTH: PUFFERY VS. FACT
Billions of dollars are spent on worthless and even harmful megavitamin therapy, especially with vitamins C and E. How did the craze for megavitamins and multivitamins come about, and why does it continue?
The Dematerialization Crusade
What have spiritualism and dematerialization added to the body of certified knowledge? Although many proponents of dematerialism have been distinguished scientists, they earned their stripes by inventing theories or methods that had little or nothing to do with that
CONFERENCE REPORT
Superstars, Timely Insights, Fun: Latest CSICon Was Biggest (and Best?) Ever
It had superstars: The witty and erudite Renaissance man Stephen
Out-of-the-Box Skepticism: Opening CSICon 2018
CSICon is always a big deal. We wouldn’t crow about
Parasites and Modern Mind Control
The headliner of the first night of CSICon was Adam
False Beliefs Handled with Care at CSICon 2018
As the first morning’s presentations came to a close at
Improving the Narrative: Enlightenment and Illusions
I want to believe. Not in UFOs but in the
It Has Always Been a Matter of Trust
Whom do you trust? I suppose the default response of
Playing Gracefully with Ideas: Stephen Fry, Evolution, and Leonardo
Massimo Polidoro described a certain someone as “a precious jewel”
COMMENTARIES
You Can’t Fit What We Skeptics Do into a Neat Box
We scientific skeptics, we skeptical inquirers, do it all. I
Embracing Option D: Knowing When You Don’t Know
I am often asked to examine seemingly mysterious and inherently
COLUMNS
Is the Glass Half Empty or Half Full? Latest Results in the Replication Crisis in Psychology
For years a chorus of voices has spoken of a
Crater Discovery Story Flawed by Premature Link to Speculative Impact Hypothesis
On November 14, 2018, science journalist Paul Voosen reported in
Interstellar Visitor Continues to Behave Strangely
In late 2017, an interstellar asteroid named ‘Oumuamua swept past
Loftus Receives Dublin’s Ulysses Medal
Elizabeth Loftus has been awarded the Ulysses Medal, University College
Scott Honored by Paleontological Society
Eugenie Scott is the recipient of the 2018 Pojeta Award
The Saga of Tom Horn
Is the Hanged Man’s Ghost Still at Large?
The Mind of Leonardo da Vinci, Part 1
Massimo Polidoro is an investigator of the paranormal, lecturer, and
Fake News about Health Products
Many of the fake news stories are attributed to organizations with credible-sounding names. These organizations either don’t exist or are copycat variations intended to be confused with actual reputable news organizations such as the Associated Press wire service
An Artist with a Science-Based Mission
Stuart Vyse is a psychologist and author of Believing in
The Science of Why Yoga Quiets the Mind
Fitness Industry Hype Obscures Yoga’s True Benefits
Bailing in the Mummies
Benjamin Radford is a research fellow at the Committee for
LETTERS TO THE EDITOR
In “Grand Illusions and Existential Angst” (November/December 2018), Alan Scott
THE LAST LAUGH
REVIEWS
First Book by the Rogues of the Skeptics’ Guide a Terrific Read
“Science is formalized reality testing.” —The Skeptics’ Guide to the
What We Know: A Lay Public Primer
At Least Know This: Essential Science to Enhance Your Life
A Look into the Transcendental Deception
Transcendental Deception: Behind the TM Curtain—Bogus Science, Hidden Agendas, and