We use cookies to track usage and preferences. See Cookie Policy
Pocketmags Digital Magazines
US
Pocketmags Digital Magazines
Christmas Presents

Was King Arthur actually Scottish?
History Scotland

Was King Arthur actually Scottish?

Posted Monday, August 24, 2015   |   3051 views   |   General Interest   |   Comments (0) Controversial research by the author of 'Finding Arthur' suggests that the fabled king of English legend was actually a Scottish warlord.

The legend of Arthur is the foundation myth of the English speaking peoples, if not the Western World, writes Adam Ardrey.  Many believe that legend is all there is, but this is only because they insist on looking in the wrong place at the wrong time: that is, in the south of Britain at… well, at any time.

Look in the right place at the right time – Scotland in the late sixth century – and Arthur steps from legend, back into history. Unlike the south of Britain, Scotland has an historical Arthur: Arthur Mac Aedan, son of the king of Scots.

The 'litmus test' for the historical Arthur is Nennius’ list of twelve Arthur-battles, the most famous of which is the battle of Badon. Professor Alcock’s map of Arthur’s battles, in his 'Arthur’s Britain', omits some of the twelve and shows others with several possible locations: he has six possible battlefields of Badon. I believe that none of Professor Alcock’s Arthur-battles are set within a sensible geographical or historical context, far less do they have an historical Arthur attached.

In the age of Arthur, Arthur Mac Aedan, things are different. The earliest historical reference to ‘Merlin’ has him at the battle of Arderydd, fought on the River Esk, the modern Scotland-England border, in 573CE. The following year Arthur, Arthur Mac Aedan was at the hillfort Dunardry, Argyll, two miles south of the hillfort Dunadd, where his father was inaugurated king of Scots in 574CE.
‘Merlin’ and Arthur; 573 and 574; Arderydd and Dunardry: these are not simple coincidences.

The land between the hillforts Dunardry and Dunadd is still, even today, called Badden, which, like Badon is a corrupt form of Baodan, a relative of Arthur Mac Aedan’s.
Stained Glass window at Stobo Church, Scottish Borders
In 574 CE Arthur Mac Aedan was inaugurated his father’s tanist (akin to vice president) on Dunadd. He placed his foot into the footprint cut into the stone on Dunadd’s summit and was given a sword to hold, just as the British queen was given a sword to hold at her coronation: when he stepped out of the footprint holding the sword, he literally took a sword from a stone. This simple step gave rise to the wonderful story of the sword and the stone.

The mysterious island of Avalon, said to be set in the western sea and where the legendary Arthur was taken after he was killed at the battle of Camlann is Iona, Argyll, the burial place of kings and more, the burial place of Arthur Mac Aedan’s family.
Oran's Graveyard Iona / Avalon where Arthur, Arthur Mac Aedan was buried
The round table and Camlann

In 2011 archaeologists discovered a round mound buried in the shadow of Stirling Castle. This find was reported under the newspaper headline 'Find Unearthed in Hunt for King Arthur’s Round Table' because Stirling is where local tradition and the written record since the 12th century CE had placed it. Stirling is only ten miles north of Camelon, Falkirk; where Arthur, Arthur Mac Aedan, fought his last battle, the battle of Camlann.

 If Arthur Mac Aedan was Arthur all twelve of Nennius’ Arthur-battles can be set in a sensible geographical, historical, context, as can Ben Arthur, Argyll, and Arthur’s Seat, Edinburgh.Merlin

Merlin was not the avuncular wizard of legend, but a scholar and politician. One twelfth-century record has him standing on Glasgow Necropolis Hill (pictured) shouting down, across the still-extant Molendinar Burn, at St. Mungo. You could not get a more precise place and time. He was assassinated by St. Mungo’s Christians at Drumelzier [sic] thirty miles from Glasgow.   (Blaise, the fictional Merlin’s mentor was in reality Cathen the Druid: known to his Christian enemies as the Blasphemer – Blaisbheum in Gaelic).

About the author
Adam Ardrey is the author of Finding Arthur published by Duckworth, London, UK & Overlook, NY, USA.
To find out more about the historical Arthur, Arthur Mac Aedan, visit Adam Ardrey’s website.

For more great articles like this get the September-October issue of History Scotland below or subscribe and save.

Single Issue - Jan - Feb 2018 Replica Edition included
$4.99
Or 499 points
6 Month Digital Subscription
Only $ 4.66 per issue
SAVE
7%
$13.99
Or 1399 points
Annual Digital Subscription
Only $ 4.50 per issue
SAVE
10%
$26.99
Or 2699 points

View Issues

About History Scotland

History Scotland is Scotland's premier history magazine, providing fascinating features on topics from all branches and periods of Scottish history and archaeology, written by leading historians, archaeologists and museum curators. The magazine is a must-read for anyone with a passion for Scotland's rich history and heritage.

More great content like this...

For more great articles like this subscribe to History Scotland today.

Most read articles this month


How do digital magazines work?

How do digital magazines work?

Digital magazines can seem like an alien experience for devoted magazine fans. Where will you be without that new glossy magazine smell? The sound of the page turning? A quiet half hour to just devour the latest news and views on your favourite hobby? More...
 3 Vegan Nice Creams from Vegan Food & Living

3 Vegan Nice Creams from Vegan Food & Living

The shades are out, the sunscreen is on and all you need to complete your summer chill is the best ice cream! More...
7 Ways to Stick to Your Workout with Your Fitness

7 Ways to Stick to Your Workout with Your Fitness

Whether it’s a busy schedule, life commitments or simply a lack of motivation, it can be tough to stay on track with your exercise regime. Your Fitness magazine asked Jim and Fiona Crossley, the founders of F45 Kingston (f45kingston.co.uk), for their tips on how to keep up with your training and achieve your fitness goals. More...
Carping4Heroes weekend raises £10k

Carping4Heroes weekend raises £10k

More than £10,000 was raised for Help for Heroes during the Carping4Heroes weekend, held for the first time at Cudmore Fisheries, Staffordshire. More...
STAFF PICK: Look magazine

STAFF PICK: Look magazine

Kate Ashley reviews Look magazine More...
Christmas Gifts for Her

Christmas Gifts for Her

Stuck for gift ideas for the lovely lady in your life? The Pocketmags team have pooled all their best ideas for gifts for her this Christmas. Get ready to earn some serious brownie points! More...
STAFF PICK: F1 Racing magazine

STAFF PICK: F1 Racing magazine

Steven Mikellides reviews F1 Racing More...
Nadiya Hussain's Tiramisu Cake

Nadiya Hussain's Tiramisu Cake

Nadiya tells Great British Food magazine: “The smell of strong coffee makes my stomach turn, but strangely enough I can just about bear the pain if I know it’s about to be mixed into cake, or tiramisu. Or – best of all – tiramisu cake!” More...
Failsafe  fingering

Failsafe fingering

In answer to a reader’s question, Graham Fitch addresses the complex subject of how to find fingering that works for you More...
7 reasons we love digital magazines

7 reasons we love digital magazines

Devoted to digital or passionate about print? Whichever side of the fence you're on, at Pocketmags we think everyone should give digital magazines a go. Here's why we love 'em. More...
Vouchers Gift Cards A magazine subscription is the perfect gift but you'll need something to show on the big day. View All
Ways to Pay Pocketmags Payment Types
At Pocketmags you get Secure Billing Great Offers HTML Reader Gifting options Loyalty Points