We use cookies to track usage and preferences. See Cookie Policy
Pocketmags Digital Magazines
Pocketmags Digital Magazines

Gay asylum seekers
Gay Times

Gay asylum seekers

Posted Sunday, November 1, 2015   |   9340 views   |   Men's Interest   |   Comments (0) It’s no secret that gay people are fleeing from the 78 countries that’ve outlawed homosexuality. But on reaching the UK, LGBT asylum seekers face discrimination, detainment and violence. Is it time the law changed?

If you list friends of the gay community for this year, The Daily Mail probably won’t be high up. After dismissing plans for classes addressing homophobic bullying as “sex lessons” a few months ago, the paper has recently zeroed in on a new target – people forced to flee governments that could stone them to death because of their sexuality.

One story in particular stands out. The Mail recently claimed signs were plastered over the Calais migrant ‘Jungle’ encouraging people to fake being gay for an easy way into the UK, suggesting those previously escaping persecution by one of the 78 countries that outlaw homosexual acts are, in fact, liars.

The problems with this come thick and fast. When asked why a story was published without a photo of the posters, The Mail claimed it never took a copy because “it doesn’t make for a very interesting picture”, adding that if we checked now, there’s a chance the signs might’ve already been taken down.

But what happens if you ask Vice reporter Sally Hayden, who saw the exact location of The Mail’s apparent sightings at the time the story was published? “No, I didn’t see any posters like that.” And what about Dr Thom Davies, whose research involved spending recent months inside the camp? “No, I’ve never seen them.” It seems there’s simply no evidence of the posters The Mail is claiming were there.

Overall, the story is yet another distraction from the bigger problem – the terrible reality facing LGBT asylum seekers. Just for starters, there’s the many people refused refugee protection in the UK due to the inherently flawed decisions based on Home Office policy. “It’s unfair, pure and simple,” says Paul Dillane, executive director of the UK Lesbian and Gay Immigration Group.

“One in five LGBT asylum cases involved stereotyped questions in a situation where it’s often a matter of life and death. We’ve had cases where people have been asked where they go clubbing in order to determine their sexuality. They assume that the first thing LGBT migrants – people living on ?5 a day – would do when arriving to the UK is go to a gay club.”
It’s this failure to understand the complexities of LGBT life that can rip apart people’s lives. Aderonke Apata, a lesbian from Nigeria, was refused asylum when interviewing officers unearthed some past heterosexual relationships. This decision was upheld, even though she showed the Home Office a DVD and photographs of her sex life with her current female partner.

The absurdity of Aderonke’s story doesn’t even touch the most gruelling aspect of many LGBT asylum seekers’ everyday life – the UK’s Detained Fast Track system. It’s a process allowing the Home Office to lock up innocent people into centres offering little privacy, lengthy integrations and open homophobia – both from other inmates and guards.

“On one occasion I was threatened by a cell mate,” says Kato, a gay asylum seeker from Uganda. “After calling me all manner of derogatory names, he said, ‘I will rape you, fuck you to death and make sure I kill you if they ever allow you to stay a night in my cell.’ It all happened in front of a prison official.”

Kato is not alone. Akiiki, another Ugandan refugee, faced the same reality in the centres: “One of the guards called me a poof and there were Jamaicans who kept hurling abuse at some Iranian guys – calling them batty men.” Another, Tahir, a gay man from Pakistan eventually granted refugee status, was sexually assaulted during his detainment.
This is precisely the environment in which gay people are expected to gather evidence that may prove their sexuality, or phone a lawyer about their case in front of other inmates. Worse still, they have only two weeks to put together their case – 14 days to come up with a lifetime’s worth of proof in a place where the threat of violence is not only real, but rife.
It’s little wonder that John Vine, the chief inspector of Borders and Immigration, expressed concerns in a report last year about the quality of decision making, when more than a quarter of initial LGBT asylum decisions were overturned at appeal. In other words, it’s a system seemingly set up to fail.

Although there’s no official statistics, the pass rate in the Home Office is well known. “We knew that for about every ten LGBT asylum seekers, only one would get through,” says Gareth Gross, who from 2001 spent ten years as an immigration officer. “A few times I’ve had unsuccessful asylum seekers contacting me just to say I was wrong. All I could do was sincerely apologise.”

Fortunately, the unfairness of the process has been acknowledged by the government and, in July this year, the centres were “temporarily suspended” by the Minister for Immigration, James Brokenshire. But it might not be long before LGBT people escaping punishment in their own country may again face being locked away guilty before proven innocent.
“I’d be very surprised if the Home Office didn’t revisit the Detained Fast Track system,” says S Chelvan, one of the country’s leading asylum lawyers. “They very much consider this the most effective way of dealing with cases they deem to be simple.” 

Although it may only be a matter of months before the centres come back, we shouldn’t ignore the progress made. Before it was ruled unlawful in 2010, gay asylum seekers could be sent back to their country of origin if it was thought it was tolerable to hide their sexuality.

And thanks to Chelvan, gay asylum seekers will never have to prove their sexuality using their knowledge of the Village People, after the Home Office adopted his interview guidelines based on stigma from their societies, rather than crude stereotypes. 

However, real equality is still a long way off for gay asylum seekers. If the LGBT community turns its back on this issue, then thousands will have to return to countries like Uganda, whose homosexuality death penalty was born out of the remnants of British colonial rule.

We must remember that the rainbow flag has a place in every country, no matter how much The Daily Mail has a problem with it. n

Some names of asylum seekers in this article have been changed to protect their identities

For more great articles like this get the November 15 issue of Gay Times below or subscribe and save.

Single Issue - February 18 Replica Edition included
Or 399 points
Annual Digital Subscription
Only $ 2.17 per issue
Or 2599 points
6 Month Digital Subscription
Only $ 2.50 per issue
Or 1499 points
Monthly Digital Subscription
Only $ 2.99 per issue
Or 299 points

View Issues

About Gay Times

Buy here then download and read on the Gay Times app for our best experience. Gay Times is the original and best lifestyle magazine for gay and bisexual men. In each issue we bring you everything from interviews with your favourite celebs to qua

More great content like this...

For more great articles like this subscribe to Gay Times today.

Most read articles this month

Christmas Gifts for Her

Christmas Gifts for Her

Stuck for gift ideas for the lovely lady in your life? The Pocketmags team have pooled all their best ideas for gifts for her this Christmas. Get ready to earn some serious brownie points! More...
Failsafe  fingering

Failsafe fingering

In answer to a reader’s question, Graham Fitch addresses the complex subject of how to find fingering that works for you More...
Christmas Gifts for Him

Christmas Gifts for Him

Why are men so hard to buy for?! If you're looking for gift ideas for the deserving gent in your life, look no further; the Pocketmags team have found some amazing gifts for him this Christmas. Boring socks begone! More...
Lift your  chances

Lift your chances

Be ready for your sixty-second chance to shine with Adrian Magson’s pitch correction More...
Great British Food's Pomegranate & Chocolate Cake

Great British Food's Pomegranate & Chocolate Cake

If you visit Morocco in autumn you will notice fresh pomegranates wherever you go. The beautiful seeds are eaten after a meal, squeezed for a refreshing drink, or scattered, jewel like, over sweet and savoury dishes. This fantastic cake uses tangy pomegranate molasses in the base and the vibrant ruby red seeds are scattered over the top to add a pop of colour and refreshing bite. More...
3 Free Reads for the New Year

3 Free Reads for the New Year

Spend all your money in December? Us too. We’ve pulled together our 3 favourite free reads available for you on Pocketmags. Everyone loves a free read! More...
Baking Heaven's Banoffee Loaf

Baking Heaven's Banoffee Loaf

Brought to you by Baking Heaven, this Banoffee Loaf is just the sweet treat you're looking for after a blustery Autumn walk. A sure-fire family hit, here’s how to make the most of this delicious Banoffee Loaf... More...
5 digital magazines for Autumn

5 digital magazines for Autumn

Ready to curl up with a new read? These autumn issues get our pick for Fall... More...
Glasgow Museums’ collection  of Anchor Line posters

Glasgow Museums’ collection of Anchor Line posters

Emily Malcolm, Curator of Transport & Technology, explores a colourful collection of historic travel posters, which convey the excitement of world travel in years gone by More...
Did your ancestor leave a will?

Did your ancestor leave a will?

For non-family historians, the appeal of a long-lost relative’s will is that they might find themselves a beneficiary. But for us, wills can provide an invaluable collection of names, relationships and clues to family members from times gone by. June Terrington examines this rich collection of records More...
Vouchers Gift Cards A magazine subscription is the perfect gift but you'll need something to show on the big day. View All
Ways to Pay Pocketmags Payment Types
At Pocketmags you get Secure Billing Great Offers HTML Reader Gifting options Loyalty Points