1 MIN READ TIME

hWHAT CAR? SAYS

The latest Countryman is far more recommendable than its predecessor, being more practical and better to drive, and we can see the appeal of its stylish interior. However, there are more niggling compromises to live with than with the other two contenders. It would win a ‘most improved’ award in this group, but it’s not quite as well resolved as its rivals.

Choosing between the Tiguan and XC40 is much more difficult. Considering they have very similar list prices, going for the more upmarket XC40 will be a no-brainer for some private buyers, plus the enticing PCP finance deals can’t be overlooked. For relatively low monthly payments, you get the best interior quality, smoothest driving manners and the comfiest ride.

The fact that the Tiguan is the most practical of our contenders, with its huge boot, will be the biggest attraction for many.There aren’t any major flaws, but its higher costs and slightly coarse engine count against it, so it narrowly loses out to the XC40.

Unlock this article and much more with
You can enjoy:
Enjoy this edition in full
Instant access to 600+ titles
Thousands of back issues
No contract or commitment
Try for 99c
SUBSCRIBE NOW
30 day trial, then just $9.99 / month. Cancel anytime. New subscribers only.


Learn more
Pocketmags Plus
Pocketmags Plus

This article is from...


View Issues
What Car?
Jun-24
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


WELCOME
WELCOME
Original Qashqai turned out to be a game-changer
FIRST LOOKS
Nissan Qashqai
Popular family SUV is refreshed with new looks and a significant technology upgrade On sale Summer Price from £32,000 (est)
Renault Captur
Small SUV gets a makeover with Scenic-like looks and Googlebased interior tech On sale Summer Price from £22,500 (est)
Alfa Romeo Junior
All-new small SUV is the Italian brand’s first electric model, with a hybrid version also on offer On sale October Price from £30,000 (est)
Vauxhall Frontera
Crossland small SUV replacement offers mild hybrid or pure electric power On sale Late 2024 Price from £25,000 (est)
FIRST DRIVES
Skoda Kodiaq
Go big or go home is this all-new SUV’s philosophy, and plug-in hybrid power is on the way Price from £36,645 On sale July
Porsche Macan Electric
Sports SUV embraces the electric age, while promising not to alienate fans of the petrol car Price from £69,855 On sale Now
Audi A3 Sportback
Facelift for this premium family hatchback brings sportier looks and a longer list of standard kit On sale Now Price from £32,630
MG 3 Hybrid+
Value - orientated small car adopts hybrid power in a bid to attract would-be Fiesta buyers On sale Now Price from £18,495
Dacia Duster
Budget-friendly family SUV is all-new, with hybrid power among the changes On sale July Price from £18,000 (est)
Mazda MX-5
How do you enhance a sports car icon like the MX-5? Very carefully… On sale Now Price from £28,015
Jeep Compass
Updates for this small SUV include a new mild hybrid petrol engine On sale Now Price from £33,910
Mini Aceman
All-new electric SUV is smaller and more affordable than the latest Countryman On sale Summer Price from £32,000 (est)
EVERY MONTH
Gov’t to investigate headlight glare
Some drivers have given up driving at night over dazzling lights
WLTP faces change due to real-world MPG discrepancies
Official test economy usually isn’t achievable in reality
Dacia extends new car warranty to seven years
Dacia warranty can be extended with each annual
EVERY MONTH
There’s already an electric version of the new
THE NEWS IN NUMBERS
£9.9bn Payouts to car owners in 2023 by
WHAT CAR? YouTube
Go to youtube.com/ whatcar for all of our
DEALS of the month
Our online New Car Deals service links you with trusted dealers who base their offers on our Target Price – so you can get your ideal car at a discount without the hassle of haggling
EVERY MONTH
WHAT IS PCP FINANCE? Unlike traditonal hire purchase
EVERY MONTH
SAVE £5262 £ Vauxhall Mokka While its petrol
Coming soon
FAMILY SUV Audi Q6 e-tron This new understudy
HONDA E:NY1
The best way to find out whether you’ll gell with a prospective new car is to try it out for an extended period. Six What Car? readers get to do exactly that with Honda’s small electric SUV
BEST AND WORST CARS FOR FUEL EFFICIENCY
Official WLTP fuel economy test results can often be misleading – a belief supported by recent high-level EU reports that suggest some models’ figures are up to 23% higher than what’s achievable in realworld use. That’s why we conduct our own Real MPG efficiency tests. Our tests are carried out under laboratory conditions to ensure repeatability, but they’re based on a real-world driving route that takes into account a wide range of road conditions. The figures reflect what’s achievable if you drive carefully, but without resorting to any extreme measures such as ‘hypermiling’. Here, Darren Moss reveals the most frugal and thirstiest petrol, diesel and hybrid cars we’ve tested, and which you can still buy today
LEAST ECONOMICAL
At the other end of the scale, running any of these thirsty beasts will cost you dearly
ADVICE
YOUR MOST FREQUENTLY A SK ED CONSUMER QUESTIONS
Faulty cars, finance repayment problems and driving offences are among the issues we get asked about most often. Claire Evans provides some answers
EVERY THING YOU NEED TO K NOW ABOUT LEASING
Leasing used to be a popular way to run a new car, with small deposits and manageable monthly payments. However, prices have shot up in the past few years, so is leasing still a good alternative to a PCP finance deal?
COMPARISONS
PRACTICAL M AGIC
Mini and Volkswagen have conjured up new models to take on Volvo’s family SUV stalwart, the XC40. Let’s see if this spells a changing of the guard
FLYING MACHINES
These super-fast, high-riding missiles sit right at the top of the spor ts SUV food chain. But which one is the king? Neil Winn has the task of finding out
OUR CARS
Mercedes-Benz EQE
300 Sport Edition
Peugeot 408
1.2 Puretech GT
BMW i5
eDrive40 M Sport
Volkswagen ID Buzz
77kWh Pro Style SWB
Ford Ranger Raptor 2.0 EcoBlue 210 4WD auto
FIRST REPORT We’re living with this potent, rugged
Vauxhall Corsa
1.2 Turbo GS
Lexus RZ
450e+ Takumi
USED CARS
Skoda Octavia
This family car may put function before fun, but it’ll put a smile on your face in plenty of other ways. Here’s how to buy the best
Easing off the drink
Luxury SUVs can be thirsty brutes, but plug-in hybrid tech means these fancy used 4x4s could be surprisingly sparing on fuel
BUYER’S GUIDE
Buyer’s guide
Class by class, the best new cars, reviewed and rated
Small cars
Family cars
Hot hatches
Small SUVs
Family SUVs
Seven-seaters
Executive cars
Luxury cars
Plug-in hybrids
Electric cars
Electric SUVs
Estates
Coupés
Convertibles
Sports SUVs
Sports cars
Performance cars
DATA
Data
Our A-Z of new cars lists every model on sale, alongside all of the important data, our road test verdicts and our star ratings
Chat
X
Pocketmags Support