2
Menu
Home
My Library
MagFest - Get 30% OFF
My Account
Pocketmags Plus+
Title A-Z
Category A-Z
Best Selling Magazines
Latest Offers
Gift Vouchers
Activate a Subscription
Blog
Help & Support
GB
0
Basket
My Account
My Library
Login
Plus+
BEST SELLERS
OFFERS
Hobbies & Craft
Aviation & Transport
Leisure
General Interest
Sport
SITE SETTINGS
GBP - £
USD - $
AUD - $
CAD - $
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
LIGHT MODE
DARK MODE
All Categories
Art & Photography
Art
Design
Architecture
Photography
Aviation & Transport
Motorbikes
Aviation
Automotive
Rail
Family & Home
Kids
Parenting
Animals & Pets
Food
DIY
Landscaping & Gardening
Property
Interior Design & Home
Food and Drink
Cooking & Baking
Drink
Vegetarian & Vegan
Gluten Free & Special Diets
General Interest
History & Fact
Astronomy
Education & Literary
Spiritual & Religion
Trade & Professional
National & Regional
Books
News & Current Affairs
Health & Fitness
Medical
Running
Women's Health
Men's Health
Slimming
Spirituality & Wellbeing
Hobbies & Craft
Collecting
Radio Control Modelling
Scale & Millitary Modelling
Sewing & Knitting
Woodworking
Arts & Crafts
Leisure Interest
Travel
Boating & Yachting
Poker & Gambling
Caravan & Motorhome
Camping & Outdoor
TV & Film
Tattoo
Horse Riding & Equestrian
Wildlife
Men's Interest
Lifestyle
Gay
TV & Film
Men's Fitness
Motorbikes
Automotive
Football
Fishing & Angling
Gaming
Gadgets
Newspapers
All
Music
Classical
Heavy Metal
Other
Rock
Pop
Practical & Playing
Hi-Fi
Sport
Football
Cycling
Rugby
Cricket & Golf
Football Programmes
Fishing & Angling
Shooting & Archery
Boxing & Martial Arts
Horse Riding & Equestrian
Other
Watersports & Board
Athletics & Running
Motorsport
Ski & Winter Sports
Outdoor & Adventure
Tech & Gaming
Apple
Gaming
Internet
Gadgets
PC
Mobile
Trade & Professional
Money & Investment
Building & Architecture
Military & Defense
Education
Media
Retail News
Farming & Agriculture
Catering
Business
Transport
Politics
Travel
Women's Interest
Hair
Celebrity
Weddings & Brides
Fashion & Lifestyle
Healthy Food & Slimming
Fitness
SITE SETTINGS
GBP - £
USD - $
AUD - $
CAD - $
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
EUR - €
LIGHT MODE
DARK MODE
Digital Subscriptions
>  
Blog
>
Questions for Fred Kiel
You are currently viewing the United Kingdom version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
Home
My Library
MagFest - Get 30% OFF
My Account
Pocketmags Plus+
Title A-Z
Category A-Z
Best Selling Magazines
Latest Offers
Gift Vouchers
Activate a Subscription
Blog
Help & Support
Gift Cards
£5
£10
£25
£50
View All
Read on any device
Safe & Secure Ordering
< 
Back to Blogs
Questions for Fred Kiel
Posted 09 October 2015   | 0 views
An executive coaching pioneer defines 'leadership character', and explains how it affects the bottom line.
You have noted that there is no widely-accepted definition of the term ‘character’. How do you define it?
I define character in two ways. First, there is the private version, which is the character you think you have, based on what’s in your heart and what your intentions are. The second version is the public version, which is how other people observe you and your behaviour. Abraham Lincoln once said that ‘character is like a tree, and reputation is like its shadow’. It would be wonderful if people judged us based on our intentions, but in fact, people judge us based on our behaviour, which, over time, adds up to our character. Think about someone you view as a person of strong character.
It’s almost certainly because of the way they behave: they tell the truth, they keep their promises, they own up to their mistakes, they show forgiveness and curiosity when other people make mistakes; and they treat people as people, not as objects. When you see someone behaving this way consistently, you admire them and you label them as having strong character.
You have identi?ed four universal principles of ‘leadership character’. Please describe them.
My colleagues and I did an extensive literature review on this subject, and we discovered, from the field of Cultural Anthropology, that there are certain human universal practices and beliefs that are shared by all cultures around the world. We selected four of those traits as being particularly indicative of character: integrity, responsibility, forgiveness and compassion. If you think about it, every parent around the globe teaches their children about integrity: they teach them to tell the truth and to keep their promises. They also teach them to be responsible for their actions, and they teach them forgiveness and compassion. These traits are universally-admired, and together, they define ‘leadership character’. We then figured out a way to put some metrics around this and ‘measure’ the character of individual leaders.
Tell us about your findings on the connection between leadership character and business results.
We enrolled over 100 CEOs in our study, and ended up with complete data sets for 84 of them. As a result, we were able to draw connections between leadership character and return on assets over the previous two years. We named this measure the Return on Character, or RoC.
What we found is that neither age nor tenure impact the bottom line. But a leader’s character does, and we measure that based on behaviour. We studied the extremes — the top-end ‘strong character’ leaders — and compared them to ‘weak character’ leaders. We called the top group Virtuoso Leaders, and the bottom group Self-Focused Leaders, for obvious reasons. We were astounded to discover that Virtuoso CEOs brought in nearly five times greater return on assets. In addition, they enjoyed a 26 per cent higher level of workforce engagement, and their corporate risk profile was much lower.
Describe the observable differences between a Virtuoso and a Self-Focused leader.
The key difference lies in how they treat people. We ended up with over 8,500 random employee ratings on these 84 CEOs, and the Virtuosos were described as demonstrating all four of the universal principles in their day-to-day behaviour. The Self-Focused CEOs were found to exhibit those characteristics half the time or less, and they were rated as ‘telling the truth’ only about half of the time.
Provide an example of a Virtuoso leader, and explain why they deserve the title.
At the top of my list is the recently-retired CEO and founder of Costco Wholesale, Jim Sinegal. Jim’s employees described him as embodying the four principles and infusing the resulting value system throughout the organization. If you think about it, everyone who visits a Costco store comes out with a smile on their face, and that’s because employees are very focused on service; they treat their ‘members’ like guests, rather than annoying customers and that’s all because of the culture Jim established.
When the company was founded in the mid-1980s, Jim made three promises. First, he promised Costco members that he would never stock anything but quality merchandise, and he would never mark it up by more than 15 per cent. Somehow, Costco buyers have found ways to get great deals, and they have stuck to that promise. For example, once they got an amazing deal on 40 or 50 grand pianos, and after the 15 per cent markup, customers were able to buy one for about $8,000 — instead of the usual $40,000.
The second promise Jim made was to his employees: that they would be treated with respect and paid a living wage. The average warehouse worker earns almost double what they pay at Sam’s Club, their closest competitor. They also close early on holidays and Sundays, so that their employees can enjoy their family lives. As a result, Costco enjoys a remarkable retention rate that is amongst the best in the retail industry. It also has a very low ‘shrink rate’ — the term used for spoiled, lost or damaged goods. Most shrink in the retail world is due to of employee theft; but Costco hardly has any of that, and they have built a culture where employees will report it if they observe it.
The third promise Jim made was to investors: that he would do his best to deliver a good return; however, that would not be the focus of the business. The focus would always be on customers and employees. For the smart investors who saw the wisdom of this approach, a USD$1,000 investment in Costco when it went public in 1985 is worth $60,000 today. That’s an annualized compound return of 16.5 per cent.
Is it possible to judge one’s own character?
People are actually very limited in their capacity to accurately judge their own character. All 84 of the CEOs in our study rated themselves as being people of very strong character, when in fact, only about 30 per cent of them were accurate. Overall, Virtuoso CEOs rated themselves a little lower than their employees rated them — indicating a certain level of humility and self-awareness. But the Self Focused CEOs rated themselves 30 points higher than their employees rated them, and higher than the Virtuosos rated themselves.
This tends to be true of people in general, and it means that about 70 per cent of us overestimate the strength of our character as perceived by others. We all tend to live in our own version of reality, and I suspect that as much as 70 per cent of us don’t have an accurate view of the strength of our own character.
Talk a bit about the traditional Economic model of human behaviour versus the newer Integrated Model, and how they relate to leadership.
Classic economic theory assumes that all people are totally rational and self-interested. The problem is, this is an inaccurate view of
We all have this dual nature of being both very selfconcerned and very ‘other-concerned’, and Virtuoso leaders are able to keep those in balance. It’s not that they sacrifice themselves totally, but they are also focused on other people and contributing to the common good. These ‘integrated beings’ are curious about the world and open to learning. This ‘updated’ view of human nature is much more complete, and it should be embraced widely.
Millennials represent 60 per cent of the global population and are on the cusp of supplying leaders to every corner of the globe. What is your message to them in terms of building character?
I think very highly of Millennials. All of the in-depth studies of them show that they’re not going to follow the path of Baby Boomers or Gen X. As the first generation of ‘digital natives’, they’re much more connected: the average Millennial has 250 friends on Facebook, and many of those are global. So, there’s this new generation of people who see themselves as part of a global community, rather than being focused on one particular culture. As a result, they will be much more focused on the common good.
They are also known to be very mistrusting of big institutions — and rightly so. They’re motivated to make those institutions change, and as they get into leadership roles, I believe they will. Of course, there are going to be some bad actors, as well as outstandingly good actors; but as a generation, they are more highly-educated and optimistic about the future than previous generations. I’m putting all of my hope for the future on them, and I will do whatever I can to empower them and educate them about the importance of character — and how to hold other people accountable to their standards.
Can character be learned?
It can, because as we discovered, the way you treat other people is a matter of habit, and habits can be changed. Before you engage with others, you don’t consciously think about how to act: you just engage in a way that feels natural to you, and that is based on the habits you’ve learned for interacting with people.
We all know someone who doesn’t treat other people well. But once you become aware of your own habits and how others really see you, you can make changes. Neuroscience is making great headway in understanding how to help people change their habits. My colleagues and I are incorporating these findings into our work, and we’re looking into using gaming as a way of taking people through simulations that provide tools for strengthening their good habits — and weakening bad ones.
Most read articles this month
Live Forever: Oasis Are Back - And These Must-Read Magazines Will Take You There
After years of speculation, it’s finally happening - Oasis are back for a 2025 reunion tour that’s sending shockwaves through the music world.
More...
Basket -
0 items
Your basket is currently empty.
Continue Shopping
Basket Total:
£
0.00
 Earning
0
Loyalty Points
Each Point is worth 1 penny or unit of currency and can be redeemed against future purchases here at Pocketmags.com
Got a discount code? Add it in the next step.
Checkout Securely
Continue Shopping
Or, read for just
99p
with
You can enjoy:
The issue in your basket
Instant access to 600+ titles
Thousands of back issues
30 days for just 99p
TRY PLUS+ FOR 99p
30 days access, then just £9.99 / month. Cancel anytime. New subscribers only.
Learn more
Chat
X
Pocketmags Support
Contact Us
Use the form below, and we’ll get back to you as soon as possible.
Send a copy of chat messages
Send Message
Message Sent
Many thanks for your enquiry.
One of our support staff will get back to you soon.
Start New Chat
Close Chat
Error In sending Email
We could not send your ticket at this time, please try again later
Start New Chat
Close Chat