US
42 MIN READ TIME

Letters

John Spinks, via email

READERS’ LETTERS

HAVE YOUR SAY

THE OTHER SIDE

I found your article on Custer’s Last Stand (Battlefield, October 2016 very interesting reading, as I had visited the site of the battle while on holiday in the USA last September. Our guide that day was a lady from the Crowe tribe who, although brought up on the reservation, had left to go to university as she felt humiliated at having to receive handouts from the United States government.

LETTER OF THE MONTH

BLOODBATH Colonel Custer’s massacring of women and children is still mourned among many Native American communities today

Custer had led a surprise dawn attack on a Cheyenne Camp at Washita River, Texas in 1868, defeating the tribe and claiming a ‘famous’ victory. In his report, he never mentioned the sheer number of women and children killed. No doubt he was keen to repeat that at Little Bighorn. His orders were to take no prisoners (which would burden his command), and in his eagerness to achieve another ‘famous’ victory, he made serious mistakes. He not only ignored his scout’s advice, but his actions subsequently made it impossible to be resupplied with ammunition. Had this been possible, he might have survived.

“Custer never mentioned the sheer number of women and children who were killed”

Although the Crowe were at that time enemies of the Sioux, because the latter were trying to take over their lands and actually scouted for the US Army, they have united with them now. This is to prevent the United States government laying the muchprotested Dakota Access Pipeline across the Sioux reservation!

John wins a copy of The Last of the President’s Men by Bob Woodward (£23, Simon & Schuster). The fascinating relationship between Nixon and his aide, Alexander Butterfield, has finally come to light in this thrilling true story of secrets, obsessions and deception at the height of the Watergate scandal.

The lady also mentioned that because the US government was not prepared to assist those on the reservation in arresting those from outside, who entered their lands and committed crimes against the natives, a Crowe Police Force had been raised to deter those would-be criminals.

Unlock this article and much more with
You can enjoy:
Enjoy this edition in full
Instant access to 600+ titles
Thousands of back issues
No contract or commitment
Try for 99c
SUBSCRIBE NOW
30 day trial, then just $9.99 / month. Cancel anytime. New subscribers only.


Learn more
Pocketmags Plus
Pocketmags Plus

This article is from...


View Issues
BBC History Revealed Magazine
Christmas 2016
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


Editor’s Letter
By royal command
Kings and queens, whether they inherited the throne or snatched
TIME CAPSULE
Snapshots
What more could you want from a seasonal welcome than
I Read the News Today
Weird and wonderful, it all happened at Christmas
FEATURES
Top 50 Kings and Queens
From the land of the pharaohs to reigning monarchs, who came out on top?
Dickensian Christmas
When family fortunes took a turn for the worse, a 12-year-old Charles Dickens was put to work in a factory. His experiences would inspire one of the greatest Christmas stories of all time
WHAT DID THE VICTORIANS EVER DO FOR CHRISTMAS?
Quite a lot, as it turns out
Battlefield: Pharsalus
It was the ultimate heavyweight contest – Rome’s two greatest leaders in a bloody fight to the finish. Julian Humphrys explains how Julius Caesar emerged as victor
The Profumo Affair
It was perhaps the biggest scandal in British political history, leading to jail sentences, suicide and the fall of a government. Anna Harris delves beneath the headlines…
Top 10 Luckiest People
Most of us will experience at least a little good fortune in our lives, but for some the luck just keeps on coming
In Pictures: Tutankhamun
The discovery of the young Pharaoh’s tomb by Howard Carter and Lord Carnarvon in 1922 proved vital to uncovering the secrets of Ancient Egypt
Great Adventures: Che Guevara
Pat Kinsella chases Che Guevara around South America, on the odyssey that shaped the political opinion of arguably the 20th century’s most celebrated revolutionary
History Makers: Attila the Hun
Described as being “born into the world to shake nations”, the king of the Hunnic Empire certainly shook Europe, but he would eventually bow to diplomacy, writes Miles Russell
Q&A
Ask the Experts
Q&A: YOU ASK, WE ANSWER
In a Nutshell
A Protestant invasion that enshrined the rights of British parliament
How Did They Do That?
The ultimate Ancient Greek war machine - a moveable siege tower
HERE & NOW
On our Radar
Looking ahead to the big events of the coming year…
Britain’s Treasures
Standing over 150 metres above sea level, this imposing tower, dedicated to the real-life Braveheart, is a fitting tribute to a legendary Scottish hero
Books
This month’s best historical books
EVERY ISSUE
A-Z of History
The end of alphabet history is upon us, but here, with as much zeal as ever, is Nige Tassell and his zany list of Zs
Chat
X
Pocketmags Support