GB
  
You are currently viewing the United Kingdom version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
25 MIN READ TIME
TOP 10

HOW GOOD ARE BRITAIN’S BEST SELLING CARS?

Do the models that topped the new car sales charts in 2024 actually deserve their popularity? We take a fresh look at the top 10 and judge each car on its merits, with no punches pulled. And we name any better alternatives that you could have bought instead

Price from £21,210 What Car? rating

10 Volk swagen Polo

Target Price is the maximum we think you should pay for your new car. It’s set by our team of mystery shoppers, who continually monitor the discounts available across the UK.

Target PCP is a fair monthly payment to aim for if you’re taking out a personal contract purchase (PCP) finance agreement. It’s based on a 48-month term with a 15% deposit and an 8000-mile annual limit, unless stated otherwise.

A FEW MOMENTS of peace; those unexpectedly warm and sunny winter days; a surprise phone call from a friend. It’s easy to take these wonderful things for granted. And in a world dominated by SUVs and continuing electric car narratives, you might argue the same is true of the Volkswagen Polo.

This small hatchback is a superb all-rounder, and in most specifications it’s nearly viceless. It’s easy to think of the Polo as the VW Golf ’s little brother, but in many regards they stand toe to toe.

It’s good to drive, although it’ll find more favour with those who seek a smooth drive than among pursuers of B-road thrills. Only the very nastiest of urban potholes can upset its composure, and motorway pockmarks cause only the mildest of fidgeting.

Aside from the breathless 79bhp version of the entry-level 1.0-litre engine, there aren’t really any duffchoices, and the 94bhp 1.0-litre is our pick of the bunch. Its output might sound weedy, but most buyers will find it more than punchy enough – so much so, in fact, that it’s not really worth paying the extra for the more muscular 114bhp version.

For a small car, the Polo makes for a surprisingly effective long-distance companion. The seats are comfortable, although highmileage drivers might prefer the even more supportive seats in higher-spec models.

There’s plenty of space inside and you can carry four six-footers with relative ease. The Honda Jazz has more space in the rear quarters, though, and it also has clever flip-up rear seat bases, something neither the Polo nor any other small-car rivals can provide.

The boot is among the biggest in the class, although bear in mind that if you choose the optional Beats audio system over the distinctly average standard set-up, the subwoofer means the boot floor is raised, robbing luggage space.

‘The Polo will find favour among those who seek a smooth drive’

All models have an 8.0in infotainment touchscreen. It’s far more basic than the set-ups in VW’s latest electric models, but it’s responsive and – with physical buttons for several functions – easy to use. Our recommended Life trim doesn’t come with sat-nav, but all models have Android Auto and Apple CarPlay connectivity, so you can use your smartphone’s navigation apps. Otherwise, you get all the basics: 15in alloys, air-con, automatic wipers and heated, power-folding door mirrors. If you want more big-car kit, stepping up to Match trim costs around £1600.

In previous years, the Polo has finished poorly in the What Car? Reliability Survey, but in the latest results it climbed to third place in the small car category; only the smaller Kia Picanto and Toyota Aygo X performed more strongly. In fact, owners reported that the Polo is now proving to be more reliable than many of VW’s more expensive models.

Polo’s supple ride is a greater draw than its handling, but it’s far from a chore on a twisty road

9 Volvo XC40

Price from £36,310 What Car? rating

The XC40’s smooth ride adds as much to its sophisticated feel as its plush, well-built interior

WHEN THE XC40 was launched in November 2017, it was a game changer for Volvo; it showed that the brand could beat premium rivals on their own turf.

Unlock this article and much more with
You can enjoy:
Enjoy this edition in full
Instant access to 600+ titles
Thousands of back issues
No contract or commitment
Try for 99p
SUBSCRIBE NOW
30 day trial, then just £9.99 / month. Cancel anytime. New subscribers only.


Learn more
Pocketmags Plus
Pocketmags Plus

This article is from...


View Issues
What Car?
Mar-25
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


WELCOME
WELCOME
March 2025
First drives
Citroën C3 Aircross
New small SUV goes big on practicality and little on cost, making it a rival for the popular Dacia Duster On sale Now Price from £20,240
Mini Cooper 5dr
Upmarket hatch is now available as a more practical five-door version while retaining its distinctive identity On sale Now Price from £24,170
Aston Martin Vanquish
Flagship from the storied British sports car brand has a mighty twin-turbo 5.2-litre V12 On sale Now Price from £332,800
XPeng G6
This electric family SUV is the first car from Chinese brand XPeng to be sold in the UK On sale Spring Price from £38,000 (est)
Fiat Grande Panda Electric
Related to the Citroën e-C3, this all-new small electric car has funky looks and a low price on its side On sale Spring Price from £20,975
Audi Q6 e-tron
Is the cheaper, rear-wheel-drive version of Audi’s latest electric SUV the pick of the line-up? On sale Now Price from £60,005
First looks
Tesla Model Y
Big-selling electric SUV gets updates to its looks, range and technology On sale May Price from £60,990
Mazda 6e
Mazda’s executive saloon returns as a sleek Tesla Model 3 rival that promises a long range On sale Early 2026 Price from £42,000 (est)
COMING SOON
SMALL SUV Toyota Urban Cruiser If you’re not
Advice
CAR SERVICING SATISFACTION: THE HEROES AND THE VILLAINS
Which workshops are most likely to keep you happy when you take your car in? Claire Evans looks at the nuts and bolts of the issue
Reader test team
Renault 4
Renault’s new small electric SUV looks back for design inspiration, but is it worth looking forward to?
Comparisons
SUV for versatile
With long ranges and the promise of great practicality and low running costs, any of these new electric SUVs could be ideal family transport. Let’s see whether Cupra, Ford or Kia makes the best all-rounder
A (20) grand day out
If you buy nearly new, you can pick up a Volkswagen Polo for the price of a brand new Suzuki Swift. We test both to see if you should
Our cars
Ford Ranger Raptor 2.0 EcoBlue Auto 4WD
FINAL REPORT
Renault Scenic Long Range Iconic
Infrequent charging stops and stress-free journeys are the benefits of having a range as long as our Scenic’s
Mini Countryman E
Exclusive Level 2
Nissan X-Trail
e-Power Tekna+ e-4orce
BYD Seal
390kW Excellence AWD
Volvo EC40 Single Motor Extended Range Plus
This electric coupé SUV is a stylish alternative to one of our favourite cars: Volvo’s XC40. But what’s it like to live with? We’re running one to find out
Cupra Formentor
1.5 e-Hybrid 272 VZ First Edition DSG
Volkswagen ID 7
Pro Match
Used cars
Audi A3 Sportback
Looking for a family hatch that’s a cut above the norm? The latest iteration of the Audi A3 is hard to beat
Origin of the species
The Volkswagen ID 4 laid the foundations for the Ford Capri. But how does it compare against Ford’s other emotively named EV – the Mustang Mach-E– as a used buy?
Buyer’s guide
BUYER’S GUIDE
‘We’ve got Best Buys for every need’
SMALL CARS
1 RENAULT CLIO Our pick 1.0
FAMILY CARS
1 TOYOTA COROLLA Our pick 1.8
HOT HATCHES
1 MERCEDES-AMG A45 Our pick S
SM ALL SUVs
ONE TO AVOID JEEP RENEGADE An easy-to-use interior
FAMILY SUVs
ONE TO AVOID LEXUS UX The UX’s
SEVEN-SEATERS
ONE TO AVOID MERCEDES-BENZ EQV This electric
EXECUTIVE CARS
ONE TO AVOID PEUGEOT 508 Although the
LUXURY CARS
ONE TO AVOID JEEP GRAND CHEROKEE Great
PLUG -IN HYBRIDS
? The best plug-in hybrids offer a long
ELECTRIC CARS
ONE TO AVOID GWM ORA 03 Despite
SMALL ELECTRIC SUVs
ONE TO AVOID LEXUS UX 300E A
FAMILY ELECTRIC SUVs
ONE TO AVOID SKYWELL BE11 This Chinese
ESTATES
? Estates are among the best cars for
COUPÉS/CONVERTIBLES
ONE TO AVOID ABARTH 500E CONVERTIBLE Nippy
SPORTS SUVs
1 PORSCHE CAYENNE COUPÉ Our pick
SPORTS CARS
1 PORSCHE 718 CAYMAN Our pick
PERFORMANCE CARS
1 BMW M3 TOURING Our pick
DATA
GONE BUT NOT FORGOTTEN
RECENT DEPARTURES FROM DATA
ADVERTISEMENT
DATA
Chat
X
Pocketmags Support