AU
  
You are currently viewing the Australia version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
123 MIN READ TIME

Behe’s Last Stand

DR. MICHAEL BEHE IS A PROFESSOR OF BIOCHEMISTRY at Lehigh University and a senior fellow of the Discovery Institute’s Center for Science and Culture, an organization noted for promoting the pseudoscientific theory of Intelligent Design (ID). He has now written his third book in attack of modern evolutionary theory: Darwin Devolves: The New Science About DNA that Challenges Evolution (2019, HarperOne). Although his views are well outside the scientific mainstream, this will not stop the efforts of the creationist and ID communities to use Behe’s work to convince school boards that ID is a valid scientific theory. Accordingly, the scientific and skeptical communities should not yield to the temptation to ignore Behe.1 Because his careful writing has the veneer of expertise, the public will look to scientists for responses to the points raised in Darwin Devolves, and I urge my colleagues to respond, not with insults, but with the only tool that matters, evidence.

At several points in Darwin Devolves, Behe makes clear his acceptance of the fact that life has evolved over billions of years and that all living things are related by universal common descent. He also acknowledges how mutation and natural selection have shaped organisms and achieved fitness gains in specific cases. Where he disagrees is the mechanism of how genetic change drives evolution of anything other than the smallest tweaks. Where science has shown that mutation and recombination provide the raw material for all of life’s diversity, Behe maintains that mutations can only break things and an intelligent intervention is required for innovation or even simple gains-of-function. To support his view, he spends a lot of time explaining, in mostly accurate detail, several cases of how mutations have diminished functions of genes with the result of improving survival, although his discussion is misleading, as I’ll explain.

Unlock this article and much more with
You can enjoy:
Enjoy this edition in full
Instant access to 600+ titles
Thousands of back issues
No contract or commitment
Try for $1.48
SUBSCRIBE NOW
30 day trial, then just $14.99 / month. Cancel anytime. New subscribers only.


Learn more
Pocketmags Plus
Pocketmags Plus

This article is from...


View Issues
Skeptic
24.1
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


COLUMNS
The SkepDoc
Is Low-Dose Radiation Good for You? The Questionable Claims for Hormesis
The Gadfly
Define Your Terms (or, Here we Go Again)
ARTICLES
Making Gasoline from Water
John Andrews and the Invention of a Legend
Online Gaming
A Virtual Experiment in the Dark Side of Human Nature
Duped by Data Mining
DATA MINING INVOLVES RANSACKING DATA AND searching
How Science Will Explain and Fix Fake News
THE INSTANT, GLOBAL SPREAD OF INFORMATION through the
The Cult of Falun Gong
How this Group Raises Big Money Using a Dance Troupe and its Own Victimhood
The Opioid Epidemic Misunderstood
DRUG OVERDOSE IS NOW THE LEADING CAUSE OF death for
Why the Human- Centered View Has Not Served us Well
“Humanity takes itself too seriously. It is the world’s
Straw Man on a Slippery Slope
The Case Against the Case Against Postmodernism
A Disproof of God’s Existence
THE TRADITIONAL DEFINITION OF GOD CREDITS HIM WITH
REVIEWS
Coddling Untruths
A Review of The Coddling of the American Mind: How Good Intentions and Bad Ideas are Setting Up a Generation for Failure by Greg Lukianoff and Jonathan Haidt
How to Know What’s Really Real
A review of The Skeptics’ Guide to the Universe: How to Know What’s Really Real in a World Increasingly Full of Fake, by Steven Novella with Bob Novella, Cara Santa Maria, Jay Novella, and Evan Bernstein.
What Are Ghosts, Anyway?
A review of Investigating Ghosts: The Scientific Search for Spirits by Benjamin Radford
Hoaxed!
Reviews of Bunk: The Rise of Hoaxes, Humbug, Plagiarists, Phonies, Post- Facts, and Fake News by Kevin Young and Hoax: A History of Deception: 5000 Years of Fakes, Forgeries, and Fallacies by Ian Tattersall and Peter Nevraumont
The Mead-Freeman Controversy 4.0
Review of Truth’s Fool: Derek Freeman and the War Over Anthropology by Peter Hempenstall.
CONTRIBUTORS
Michelle E. Ainsworth holds an MA in history. She enjoys
JUNIOR SKEPTIC
QUEST FOR THE TRUTH ABOUT DUNGEONS & DRAGONS
Today we’ll sharpen our pencils, pick up our magical
INVENTING WARGAMES
As we’ll learn, role-playing games (RPGs) such as Dungeons
PLUNGE INTO FANTASY
Strategy board games like Risk were complicated enough
A DARKER MAZE
It took a year to sell the first thousand Dungeons
THE SATANIC PANIC
Fear of Satanic cults trickled first through certain
D&D’s TRIUMPHANT RETURN
Eventually the Satanic Panic faded away. The FBI concluded