GB
  
You are currently viewing the United Kingdom version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
21 MIN READ TIME

PORCUPINE TREE

Porcupine Tree: still one of modern prog’s finest bands.
Steven Wilson: bring on those long songs!
TAYLOR NETTNIN Gavin Harrison, he’s a master of creative rhythms.

VENUE AUDITORIUM THEATRE, CHICAGO, USA

DATE 20/09/2022

Late last year, progressive behemoths Porcupine Tree announced their big comeback. After being apart for more than a decade, they’re finally back on the road, on their first tour in 12 long years, promoting the acclaimed Closure/Continuation. The energy in Chicago’s beautiful Auditorium Theatre is palpable as they take the stage. Porcupine Tree receive the sort of welcome that’s usually reserved for the gods. Opener Blackest Eyes, from 2002’s In Absentia, sets the tone for what’s to come: fans rise from their seats and don’t sit back down for the entirety of the two-set performance. Frontman and guitarist Steven Wilson says he hopes they’re ready for a long night of music and we all rowdily approve, much to his satisfaction.

Although Wilson confesses that he and his bandmates are unwell on this rainy September evening – something he jokes always seems to happen by the time they reach Chicago – the live quintet are utmost professionals and push through, feeding off the auditorium’s energy and rising to every occasion.

“Porcupine Tree may be getting older, but they’re still at their peak.”

The setlist features Closure/Continuation almost in its entirety, with lead single Harridan one of the standouts. The song has a decisive John Wetton-era King Crimson bass line carried out tonight by new boy Nate Navarro and a vocal melody by Wilson. The first set is crammed with more standout tracks from the current record, including Rats Return, which packs a punch and features mean tritone riffs from Wilson and new live guitarist/backup vocalist Randy McStine (McStine & Minnemann), and notable creative rhythms from drummer Gavin Harrison (King Crimson, The Pineapple Thief). Harrison remains workmanlike throughout the show and his hard-hitting technical prowess and creativity retain the audience’s full attention.

As fantastic as the music sounds, Porcupine Tree’s visuals are just as astounding and immersive. New track Herd Culling, which has all the makings of an instant classic, is enhanced by a first-person video of someone running away from a red-eyed, bloodthirsty wolf. The longserving Richard Barbieri provides a multitude of layered synth sounds that really add to the song’s (and video’s) haunting quality. Wilson paints a creepy picture with his lyrics, ‘Son, go fetch the rifle now, I think there’s something in the yard’ and it finishes with a furious guitar solo that sounds like it could have been on Pink Floyd’s Animals.

Wilson wears his guitar strap low and roams around barefoot, giving off something of a grunge vibe. Although Porcupine Tree are progressive in every sense, the raw spirit of Kurt Cobain lingers too; their sound fluctuates from pristine to livewire, and it’s those ebbs and flows that make the fans hoot and holler throughout the show. Wilson mentions there are some notes he isn’t destined to reach this evening and jokes about an unnamed but notable musician who blames an off-note vocal “on the AC, the alcohol and cocaine”. The punchline receives an eruption of laughter, yet despite his current illness, Wilson’s performance is of a high calibre and remains so as the show progresses.

The highlight of the night comes towards the end of the second set when Wilson asks the crowd if they “want something long?” Porcupine Tree then break into Anesthetize from the 2007 album Fear Of A Blank Planet. The near-18-minute epic with multiple passages starts by putting the audience in a trance with a slow, Tool-like build before it moving into a headbanging section and then back to a soothing build-down as Wilson’s melody is backed by a steady groove from Harrison. It takes the crowd on a journey into dystopia. ‘We’re lost in the mall, shuffling through the stores like zombies,’ sings Wilson to an audience that hangs on his every word.

Unlock this article and much more with
You can enjoy:
Enjoy this edition in full
Instant access to 600+ titles
Thousands of back issues
No contract or commitment
Try for 99p
SUBSCRIBE NOW
30 day trial, then just £9.99 / month. Cancel anytime. New subscribers only.


Learn more
Pocketmags Plus
Pocketmags Plus

This article is from...


View Issues
Prog
Issue 134
VIEW IN STORE

Other Articles in this Issue


REGULARS
Discovering
White Knight Records is a collaboration between Rob
Ed’s Letter
Stream the Prog 134 playlist at www.spoti.fi/3fIdy3I
Bloody Well Write
Send your letters to us at: Prog, Future Publishing, 121-141 Westbourne Terrace, London, W2 6JR, or email prog@futurenet.com. Letters may be edited for length. We regret that we cannot reply to phone calls. For more comment and prog news and views, find us on facebook.com under Prog.
INTRO
IF IT’S OUT THERE, IT’S IN HERE
Q&A
DAVID PAICH
DARK AND GREY: SIX OF THE BEST
Forty years ago, Genesis’ classic line-up reunited for a one-off show at the Milton Keynes Bowl. Billed as Six Of The Best, its aim was to raise money for Peter Gabriel’s then debtridden WOMAD project. Although the concert was never recorded, it holds a special place in the hearts of bandmembers and fans alike, who look back and recall the time that one of the UK’s biggest prog bands performed in a very muddy clay pit.
HUGH BANTON
Every month we get inside the mind of one of the biggest names in music. This issue it’s Hugh Banton. As Van der Graaf Generator’s longestserving keyboard player, his distinctive organ lines have underpinned the band’s best-known songs over three key periods of their career. Here, the one-time BBC engineer and organ builder recounts VdGG’s formative years and their reunion in the mid-00s – as explored in the new box set, Interference Patterns. He reveals to Prog why he’s proud of their creative output… and why he finally accepts the prog rock label.
JEAN-MICHEL JARRE
Progressive electronic pop doyen goes on a binaural odyssey by way of a trip back to Paris and 1968.
ORGAN REFRAMED
VENUE UNION CHAPEL, LONDON DATE 16/09/2022 Considering its
A SUNDAY IN SEPTEMBER
Voyager: kings and queen of prog singalongs! VENUE
MY PROG
HANS RUTTEN (THE GATHERING)
FEATURES
Waiting To Happen
It was their second album with vocalist Steve Hogarth, but Marillion’s Holidays In Eden was far from an easy ride. Originally released in 1991 and recently reissued as a deluxe package, the band’s sixth studio release found them struggling to replicate the commercial success they’d enjoyed in the 80s without compromising themselves artistically. Hogarth, Mark Kelly and Pete Trewavas look back on the challenges of creating their ‘pop’ album.
Black Moon
Since she emerged on the post-rock scene in 2019, British singer-songwriter AA Williams has defied expectations and followed her own path. Whether that’s through performing with experimental Japanese group MONO, reworking her debut EP with a 10-piece string ensemble, or giving Radiohead’s Creep a haunting makeover. Prog catches up with her to discuss her reflective second album, As The Moon Rests, and staying sane.
All God’s Children
King’s X have described it as “the most enjoyable album” they’ve recorded to date and Three Sides Of One serves as a reminder that the trio have no plans to pack up their instruments. Despite having had a challenging few years, bassist and frontman Dug Pinnick tells Prog why the time was right to make a bold return with their first new material in 14 years.
Theory of evolution
With a new singer and a new album, the future looks bright for Arena. Prog catches up with co-founder member Clive Nolan and new vocalist Damian Wilson to hear more about their 10th record, The Theory Of Molecular Inheritance, and how they’re finding a new lease of life nearly 30 years in.
The Post-War Dream
On Robin Armstrong’s ninth album as Cosmograf, he turns to the past in the hope of building a better future. The musician tells Prog about the fictional World War Two veteran at the heart of Heroic Materials and the music that inspired his tale.
Between The Lines
After much critical acclaim was heaped on their 2017 epic, Legends Of The Shires, prog metal exponents Threshold are back with their 12th studio album, the darkly brooding Dividing Lines. With tensions between bandmembers past and present now resolved, founding guitarist and producer Karl Groom sheds some light on the bleak themes it explores.
All The Rage
Forty-one years ago, Ultravox entered Conny Plank’s studio in West Germany to record the follow-up to the hugely successful Vienna. They had no songs and no ideas, but over the course of several months, the experimental Rage In Eden began to take shape. Midge Ure, Billy Currie and Warren Cann reminisce over the creation of an album that not only reached the UK Top 5 but also earned them comparisons to Genesis!
Bleed From Within
When …And You Will Know Us By The Trail Of Dead celebrated their 25th anniversary in 2020 with the release of X: The Godless Void And Other Stories, they certainly weren’t planning on creating a follow-up quite so soon. Two years on, multi-instrumentalist Conrad Keely tells Prog how XI: Bleed Here Now was inspired by a certain Canadian band and why they decided to embark on their very own journey into quadraphonic sound.
Joy is of essence of success!
Across their previous two albums, Heilung have used dark progressive neofolk to provide a window into Europe’s past. But on their latest, the experimental collective pay tribute to early civilisations a little further afield. Composer and throat singer Kai Uwe Faust explains how they’ve used ancient instruments, arcane scrolls and algebra to bring the mysterious Drif to life.
Chat
X
Pocketmags Support