This website use cookies and similar technologies to improve the site and to provide customised content and advertising. By using this site, you agree to this use. To learn more, including how to change your cookie settings, please view our Cookie Policy
Pocketmags Digital Magazines
Pocketmags Digital Magazines
   You are currently viewing the United Kingdom version of the site.
Would you like to switch to your local site?
Digital Subscriptions > The Oban Times & Lochaber Times > 20th April 2017 > Meet the candidates hoping for your vote in next month’s council election

Meet the candidates hoping for your vote in next month’s council election

Derek Connery explains the complicated single transferable vote system that sees the electorate rank those standing by numerical preference on the ballot

AS WE approach May the Fourth (be with you), a celebration of all things Star Wars, our local elected and prospective officials have muscled in and are holding the council elections on the same day.

This election will see the single transferable vote (STV, not the TV channel) system being used again as it has been in Scotland for all local council elections since 2007.

Now the $64,000 question: how does it work? I thought I knew roughly but, in truth, I was clueless. It is quite a complicated system all told but it is thought to be fairer than the traditional first past the post (FPTP) methods and ensures that no vote is wasted.

This seems great in theory, but surely if you use a system that people struggle to understand then there is a problem and a lack of comprehension of the methodology is counter-productive to what you are trying to achieve in the first place.

So I am going to try to add some clarity to the proceedings.

The first rule of STV is the cross is out the window - we’re using numbers. Let’s imagine that a ward will have four members and on polling day eight candidates are standing. You would begin with a number one for your preferred candidate, two for your second choice and so on.

Okay stop! You are not required to rank all the candidates. In fact, if you choose just only one, that is fine. However, if you rank all of them you potentially ‘assist’ a candidate that you wouldn’t vote for in a month of Sundays.

Right, so now everyone has voted, the polls are closed and we are ready to start the count.

In this case, let’s say that 1,000 votes have been cast. Ah, but before the counting starts the returning officer has some homework to do. They have to work the ‘quota’. This is the number of votes required to win the seat. In FPTP, this was easy as it was who got the most votes. Duh!

In STV, the quota (sometimes referred to as the droop quota) is worked out as follows.

Valid votes cast/ (number of seats available+1)+1 = quota. So for our example 1,000/ (4+1)+1 = 201. This means that any candidate who achieves 201 votes or more is duly elected.

So the next job is to count the ballot papers and see how many first choice votes each candidate got, for example

Candidate 1 = 100

Candidate 2 = 50

Candidate 3 = 150

Candidate 4 = 250

Candidate 5 = 30

Candidate 6 = 199

Candidate7 = 201

Candidate 8 = 20

This means that candidates four and seven are duly elected. So as the quota is 201, none of number seven’s votes are re-allocated. However, 49 of number four’s votes have to be redistributed.

This is done by now looking at second preference on all the papers that had number four as first choice and excluding number seven as they are already elected.

Candidate 1 = 20

Candidate 2 = 30

Candidate 3 = 150

Candidate 5 = 20

Candidate 6 = 25

Purchase options below
Find the complete article and many more in this issue of The Oban Times & Lochaber Times - 20th April 2017
If you own the issue, Login to read the full article now.
Single Issue - 20th April 2017
Or 99 points
Annual Digital Subscription
Or 3299 points
6 Month Digital Subscription
Or 1799 points

View Issues

About The Oban Times & Lochaber Times

Fort William Laggan family loses fight to stay Oban Chemical threat to Mull wildlife Cancer patient sacked and evicted Includes Scotfest17 your 16 page guide to festivals in Argyll, the Highlands and beyond

Other Articles in this Issue